The Challenges of Managing Diverse Teams

This blog mainly help the managers or leaders to manage different backgrounds, cultures people and provide the better results into the diverse team. Ibarra and Hansen (2011) indicated that leaders has the responsibilities to lead different disciplines and generations people together. This situation is particularly evident in the multinational corporation like BCG in China. As a US company, BCG would like to develop their business and scope in China, the managers or leaders about the issue how to deal with diverse team for the core task to produce a better result.

‘There are lots of conflicts in my team, we always have divergences to deal with issues, as a leader, how can i improve it and handle it??’ Many leaders would have the same challenges in managing diversity.

diversity

Distefano and Maznevki (2000) presented that with economy increasingly requires people to collaborate and sometimes members scattered across a city or the globe, these teams should create significant advantages to add great value. Each members in the team have a common goal and mission statement to achieving mutual cooperation. Diverse team which is also a key concern for theory and practice in organizational behavior, attempting to integrated diversity with performance becomes a challenge (Carsten et.al 2004)

Hofstede’s Model

hofstede

Geert Hofstede is a successful person to explain the knowledge of culture, his dimensions of national cultures dealt with four areas that different national society handle differently (Mullins 2013). However, Hofstede’s model also have some limitations. Because of the early research sample is not comprehensive, with the development of economy in many developing countries, like China. This would also reflects the outcomes to some extent about diversity.

According to Hofstede (2010) leaders need to using this model to distinguish the different between some kinds of cultures from power distance, role culture and task culture etc. in order to manage the problem that diversity will bring about.

How to Manage Diversity?

Respecting every members in group: whether in a what kind of role, everyone should be respected. If a person can get respect, he or she will get a psychological comfort to stimulate their enthusiasm for their work, but not always work in a often discriminated against or belittle in bad environment.

Motivation and collaboration: Every member would be a very important part in this group, just like a component in a machine, lacking of any of one that machine would not work even broken down in the last. So, in a diverse team, leaders would be able to motivate employees passion in their work and improve the energy of their collaboration to make a better performance.

Having an open-door policy: Leaders may have to be more comfortable in making decisions and different people like to raise issues in different ways, and they would decrease their passion an satisfaction in strict polity as well. So, it is important to base on the open-door policy to encourage everyone, leaders need to be seen to be listening to , and acting on, the concerns of their diverse teams (Rodriguez 2006).

Example of Managing Diverse Team

BCG_Logo

Benefiting from the rapid of growth of economic rate and international status, Chinese management consulting industry is to learn from the Europe and the U.S. enterprise theory and experiences. As for BCG, the world well-known consulting enterprise expand their field in China, in the enterprise management work, knowing the differences between Chinese and American cultures, in order to forgiveness of each national culture, and strengthen communication with each other.

As a multinational corporation, the managers definitely will faced with the problem with dealing with the diverse culture and team. In China, compared with traditional cultures and backgrounds, foreign background will more fresh in China’s business environment, like business type, leading style and business culture. So in China, managers in foreign enterprise would like to concentrate on how to deal with diversity and add more value to organisation. For example, leaders are able to prefer to respect everyone in group and motivation everybody to discover their own value to perform better in appraisal system (Jackson et.al. 2003). So that, despite the management skills of leader, how to handle and work with diverse team might be a compulsory skills in business sectors.

Conclusion and Recommendation

It is a common situation for the leaders or managers to face diverse teams in the organisation. In contemporary society, not only culture and background can be a factor in diversity, gender and disabled situation also influence the diversity.

1

How to manage them seen more significantly important for the leaders considering. To encourage employees respect and accept workplace diversity, avoiding prejudice and ethnocentrism, so that, managing diverse team in the right way can make organisation gain more committed and better financial performance.

 

 

References List:

Carsten, K.W. et.al. (2004) ‘Work Group Diversity and Group Performance: An Integrative Model and Research Agenda.’ Journal of Applied Psychology 89(6),1008-1022

Distefano, J.J. and Maznevski, M.L. (2000) ‘Creating Value with Diverse Teams in Global Management’. Organizational Dynamics, 29(1), 45-63

Hofstede, G. and Mooij, M. (2010) ‘The Hofested Model: Applications to Global Branding and Advertising Strategy and Research’. International Journal of Adertising, 29(1),85-110

Ibarra, H. and Hansen, M.T. (2011) ‘Are You a Collaborative leader?’ Harvard Business Review, 89(7-8),68-74

Jackson,S.E., Joshi, A. and Erhardt, N.L. (2003) ‘Recent Research on Team and Organizational Diversity: SWOT Analysis and Implications’. Journal of Management, 29(6),801-830

Mullins, L.J. (2013) Management & Organisational Behaviour. 10th edn. UK: Pearson Education Limited.

Rodriguez, R. (2006) ‘Diversity Finds its Place.’ HR Magazine 5(1), 56-61

Leadership and Ethics

This blog mainly illustrates definition about the ethical leadership and 4-model to explore it about how the model influence the ethical leadership, then examples will indicate about two examples for the ethical leadership and unethical leadership.

How do you think about ethics? Do you think how much importance the ethical leadership would be affect the organisation??

The Center for Creative Leadership (CCL) in 2010 indicated that leadership is the product of multiple factors, as a concept of representing a value of an integrated organisation, commitment and loyalty of employees. Ethics which is a vital factor to become a leader, according to BBC ethics (2015) ethics is a systematic moral principles, concerning with what is good for individuals and organisation, which can provide a moral map. As a kind of behavioral category, ethical leadership would become a fruit of leadership development.

What is Ethical Leadership?

Figure1: The 4-V Model of Ethical Leadership (2010)

111

As Padgett and Rau-Foster (2012) presented that, in the past few years, business thinkers would believe that ethical leadership is simply a matter of leaders who can set example for other and strive against any temptation. Ethical leadership is under the testing by theories and comprehensive perspective for a development (Brown and Harrison 2005). Without denying creating values and importance of character, the reality of ethical leadership is more complex and flexibility.

ethical leadership
As for Rubin (2010) posted that Ethical leadership a appropriate conduct  to reflect correct actions and personalities in kinds of aspects. Ethics is also a value-driven form of leadership that affects the self-position and beliefs, which has two benefits, one plays in creating a fixed point in decision making, the other one is the increase in performance in organisations (Cameron 2011).

By using 4-V models, it can discover the values of managers and leaders, for an excellent leader who would to be a responsibility for the followers and using their voice to motivate them, influencing organisation to a correct way, like Jack Ma give a big push to young person about the encourage to build their own business related to the e-commerce. Despite a responsible value,  leadership with a virtue way make the organisation and leaders achieve their goals by seeking the correct values and vision.

 

Two Principle Areas of Ethics Leadership


  • Deontological

Deontological can be described as kinds of duties or rules. According to Mullins (2013) posted that deontological ethical leadership emphasis things must be done which is irrespective of the consequences. However, we cannot convince all the duties are relevant or rules are correct, especially obtain an acceptable result at last.


  • Teleological

Teleological, which likely relate to consequentialist, pay more attention to the results and the effects of results bring about (Day 2012). However, despite consequentialist view of ethics play an important role in dealing with issues in everyday, it is difficult to solve all problem.

Great Ethical Leaders in China – Jack Ma, CEO of Alibaba

马云1

Jack Ma is the founder and executive in Alibaba, who is focused on the small e-commerce business and try to provide more chance in the period which was not developed in e-commerce and cannot accepted. Jack gave a big push to encourage young people to create a fresh business, creating a platform to support their business as well. A ccording to Dempsey (2015) posted a leader can have much value in the organisation and his personal responsibility, deeply affecting all of people in this organization and the leadership of the organization’s development direction and future. In addition to that, Jack Ma use his spare time to protect the environment and positively attend several kinds of charities, creating value and brand recognition. However, Alibaba also has many competitors around the world, such as Amazon and E-bay.

Jack Ma used his ethical leadership style and globalization vision to enhance more values to compete the intense rivals.

马云3

Unethical Leadership Example

FIFA

By contrast, there are also many unethical leadership behavior in contemporary society. Just like ‘FIFA Corruption Crisis’, according to BBC news (2015), FIFA has been engulfed by claims of widespread corruption since summer 2015, several presidents and senior executive were faced legal sanctions. Executives accepted bribes to tamper the decision of organizers.

In conclusion, ethics would be a successful and excellent factors for executive to manage and influence followers. Both two principles emphasis lead to a more correct goodness development result and tendency. A successful ethical leader in the company has their own responsibility and creating deep value for organisation and individuals. Ethical leadership need to know both kinds of things how to do things right and conduct right things. However, there are also challenges in Ethical leadership, ethics can be complex, like demand of policies and atmosphere in  organisation, improving the exact line for ethics would be core issue for managers. So that, by using ethical leadership avoid such kind of incorrect decision and action, leading the organisation to produce a better result and gain a sustainable development for a long term.

References List:

BBC (2015) Ethics: A General Introduction. [online] available from<http://www.bbc.co.uk/ethics/introduction/intro_1.shtml> [6 May 2015]

BBC News (2015) Fifa Corruption Crisis: Key Questions Answered. [online] available from<http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-32897066&gt; [21 December 2015]

Brown, M.E. and Harrison, D. (2005) ‘Ethical Leadership: A Social Learning Perspective for Construct Development and Testing’. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 97(2), 117-134

Cameron, K. (2011) ‘Responsible Leadership as Virtuous Leadership’. Journal of Business Ethics 98(1) 25-35

Day, D.V. and Antonakis,J. (2012) The nature of leadership. 2th edn. United Kingdom.SAGE Publications,Inc.

Dempsey, J. (2015) ‘Moral Responsibility, Shared Values, and Corporate Culture’. Business Ethics Quarterly 25(3) 319-340

Leadership and Talent Development in International Humanitarian and Development Organizations (2010) ‘Leadership Introduction’[online] available from <http://www.alnap.org/resource/9672&gt; [2010 n.d.]

Padgett, B.L. and Rau-Foster, M. (2012) ‘Leadership Ethics: An Introduction’. Business Ethics Quaterly 22(3) 601-604

Rubin, R.S. et al. (2010) ‘Do Ethical Leaders Get Ahead? Exploring Ethical Leadership and Promotability’. Business Ethics Quaterly 20(2), 215-236